Susei no Gargantia Weekly Update – Episode 2

Susei no Gargantia Weekly Update - Episode 2

I decided against taking an in-depth look at Susei no Gargantia and instead focus on how the show has improved in its second outing. Surprisingly it’s a bit more enjoyable than the debut, but there are still problems that linger.

Letting Amy, performed by Hisako Kanemoto, have a much larger role in this episode added some much needed character to the show. Kanemoto’s voice acting does much to liven up the atmosphere. I’m not saying the performances behind Chamber or Ledo are bad, but their monotone quality desperately needed Amy’s bubbly atitude to create some contrast and texture in the dialogue.

Amy Surprised Again

The overall visual direction improves as well. There seems to be much more detail in the backgrounds, now manicured with extensive amounts of CG that highlight many of Gargantia’s moving parts. Lighting and color selection help frame  the beautiful visual set pieces. These two elements give the show a much more cohesive look that’s both bright and lively.

Amy and Friends

My favorite part of the episode though is the exploration of the language and cultural divide between Ledo and the crew of the Gagantia. There are little nuances in the script that depict how human life in space is different than life on Earth. At one point Amy offers Ledo some fried fish, which he is hesistant to eat because Chamber describes it to him as a corpse. He reluctantly accepts the gift after he see’s Amy eat half of it. The whole moment serves as a lens, as the script gives the audience a bit of food for thought: How different is life in the celestial heavens?

Ledo and Amy

Now the one thing that hasn’t really changed is the action sequences. They are still slow and plodding and dont do much to change the pacing of the episode. The final scene where Ledo takes on the pirates moves just as quickly as the twenty minutes of dialogue before it. Sadly the only reason I haven’t moved this down to the ugly is because the terrible sequence was placed at the end of the episode rather than the beginning.

Bellows' Crew Surrounded

I’ll be really disappointed if the action continues to be this sluggish. Sure, my expectations might be a bit inflated because mechas and pirates are involved, but the choreography in these moments don’t even imitate mediocrity. These are harsh criticisms but I’m glad the sequence only takes up a fraction of the episode.

Ledo and Chamber in Action

The series as a whole has a lot of potential, and I hope it can continue to improve on its weaknesses. If it does that it might become something truly special by the time the conclusion rolls around. Production I.G., please don’t let me down!

3 thoughts on “Susei no Gargantia Weekly Update – Episode 2

  1. Despite the weaknesses you pointed out, I definitely think Susei no Gargantia is set to be one of the best anime shows of the new spring season – maybe even the best, depending on how Hataraku Maou-sama! works out. Thus far I don’t actually mind the sluggish action scenes too much, but that’s probably mostly because I tend to prefer character-based anime to begin with. I agree though, if Susei no Gargantia is going to put action scenes in at all, they shouldn’t be half-assed.

    • I always point to Bakenonogatari as a character based drama that did action right. The few scenes it did have helped break up the monotony of the dialogue. Going forward though I think that this series might try to move away from action and focus more on Ledo and how he grows to find a home on earth.

      • I confess to not having watched Bakenonogatari yet. However, I have seen another of Nishio Ishin’s adaptations, Katanagatari – also featuring a heap of dialogue but with action scenes that are really well done. If Bakenonogatari is anything like Katanagatari in terms of tone/atmosphere, I have a feeling I’d enjoy it very much.

Comment to Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s