Toaru Majutsu no Index Retro Review [Below Average]

Toaru Majutsu no Index Retro Review [Below Average]Not even god can help…

Title: Toaru Majutsu no Index
TV Series; Episodes 24
Genre: Action, Science Fiction, Harem
Produced: J.C. Staff

How do you mess up mixing magic, science fiction, action and women? The answer is quite elementary my dear reader. You coat it all in a veneer of convoluted mythology that tries to make sense of itself every once in a while. Then have the gall to rewrite the rules of the world whenever you deem necessary to make a ‘not-so-interesting’ plot point slightly more confusing. While watching Toaru Majutsu no Index I felt that I, as a viewer, was quite stupid for not understanding exactly what was going on, even though a character on screen had explained for  a good five minutes what the situation was. An easy solution to these problems would be to scrap all the superfluous magitech and physics mumbo jumbo and just focus on building a world that’s intuitive to understand.

Instead the show seems fixated on firing information at the viewer at rapid pace. Much of the problem lies in the show trying to delineate between two factions, Magic and Science. It goes on to explain the differences between the two but not in a meaningful way. Mostly because the characters, which serve as foundations for each of their respective sides, often have their objectives shrouded in vagueness and their allegiances flip flopping between both groups. It blurs the divide the series tries so hard to define.

Surprisingly the structure of the plot is quite simple. The story follows Kamijou Touma, a rather insignificant high school student with a rather significant power. His right arm can negate any ability, be it magic or genetic. The series documents his adventures as he goes around helping various young women because of his selfless and heroic personality. He unwittingly adds each of them to the roster of his harem, which at times looks more like middle school classroom. It’s a tried and true, if somewhat tired, formula that plagues most light novel adaptations. The linearity of such a plot structure helps give the show some direction in the fugue of its mythology.

Most of the characters are flat as their chests. It’s a simple statement that sums up the level of development of the cast. This can be directly attributed to the problems with the story. Most of the dialogue is used to explain what is going on rather than act as a vehicle for character growth. Even the leads, who have substantial screen time, spit out the same one liners throughout the entirety of the show’s length. How many times will Touma tell me that he wants to fix a situation just because it ‘seems’ wrong?

The one shining star in the entire constellations of negatives is the production. There is a great use of color thats helps separate out different arcs by color scheme. It gives each segment a strong sense of personality and theme. In addition, the fluidity of the animation and the action sequences never dip in quality and deliver some excellent set pieces, such as a giant clay golem rampaging through an underground mall. Even though the  show is about five years old, the polish on the art lets it hold up by today’s standards.

Aurally, Toaru Majutsu no Index is just as pleasant. Both opening themes by Kawada Mami are fantatsic. Her strong voice accompanies the mass of synths to weave some incredibly catchy tunes. IKU succeeds with the closing themes as well, painting some strong ballads. The only sore spot in the sound would be Yuka Iguchi’s performance as the title character Index. Her voice doesn’t have much depth and seems to be constantly stuck in an annoying whine.

Toaru Majutsu no Index could have been a good series. Hell, it could have been a great series if it just showed some focus. If it had left the fat on the cutting room floor, some more room could have been made for the characters and the actual story itself. At the end of the day what left is a flaccid cast drowning in an overwritten story.

Category Score
STORY Below Average
OVERALL Below Average

5 thoughts on “Toaru Majutsu no Index Retro Review [Below Average]

  1. Index has a great idea for a story, but certain characters *cough* index.Touma *cough* ruin the series! I mean SURE season two and bits of season one show Index using her magical powers, but they never really explore that aspect…I was always annoyed by that fact because the series is called INDEX! Yet it is 99% about Touma giving speeches before punching them in the face.

    The best thing that Index did was introduce us to Accelerator, Last Order, Misaka and Kuroko! Which gave us the very popular Railgun spin off series, and yes I know Touma does appear in that as well; however he never becomes the main focus.

    I like the idea of Index and Railgun I just wish it got a bit more love from the ani-sphere xDD

    • Reason why you don’t see Index using magic because she doesn’t have the one thing that really fuels magic which is mana. What you saw in season two wasn’t magic. It was more like chanting and disruption of spells. What you saw in the first arc of season one was a control mechanism that prevents anything tampering with the property of the Angelican church.

      • True that silentcid you are right the stuff in Index s2 was more of a chant based thing like you said, but I kind of wish they named the series after Touma instead because he does EVERYTHING in that series >.>

        I wish they would have explored more of her various powers, but yeah of course the church does block most of her magical ability…

Comment to Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s